
Ned Yost has always taken a liking to Craig Counsell, but this month he's taken his fixation with him to another level. Counsell has basically become the Brewers' every day third basemen. Why is he starting every day? That's a very good question.
The Bill Hall/Russell Branyan platoon has combined for 26 home runs and 66 RBI this season. Craig Counsell has one home run and 12 RBI. Hall and Branyan don't carry the greatest looking batting average, but neither does Counsell. Hall and Branyan together is almost like having another Prince Fielder in the lineup. With Branyan now out due to injury, that leaves the Brewers with just Counsell and Hall battling for time at the hot corner.
The reason Yost seems to like Counsell so much is because of his defense. He has a sure handed glove pretty much anywhere in the infield, but is that enough reason to start him every day? The difference he makes defensively is not a big enough reason to start him over Hall as their offensive production isn't even close.
The only reason I can think of why Yost continues to send Counsell out there is because he has a decent on base percentage compared to how putrid his batting average is. Counsell is hitting .229 but has an OBP of .333. What is so puzzling to me is the timing of this. July was Bill Hall's best month of the season while Counsell had one of his worst months in July. In July, Hall hit .288 with a .350 on base percentage, four home runs, and 16 RBI. July wasn't as kind to Counsell as he only hit .174 with a .286 on base percentage, and 1 RBI.
I have no problem with Craig Counsell as a role player. His fine defense makes him a solid option off the bench, and a defensive option with the lead in a late inning game. He is just not an every day player. It makes no sense that Yost stopped giving Hall playing time when he was tearing the cover off the ball and Counsell hasn't been hitting all year.


12:50 PM
Pete


















